96 points, Decanter
"This preview of the 2023 Clos de la Roche at Ponsot shows a wine of intensity and elegance, with ripe blackberry fruit, hints of violets and a savoury, salty mineral note. At this point, the wine is still closed and not displaying its richness, but a dynamic freshness and vivacity carry it to an impressive finish. Although a more difficult vintage than 2022, the wine shows transparency and clarity of fruit. For best results, wait at least five years before opening."
96 points, Tim Atkin MW
"Ponsot is by far the largest landowner of Clos de la Roche with a whopping 3.35 ha in three big blocks, and all are included here this vintage. The color is impressively dark, even with a hint of russet coming through. Spice drawer and toast slowly eke from the glass. The palate tags on blackberry coulis, underbrush and fireplace embers. The structure is imposing but artfully crafted with everything nicely aligned. Grainy tannins link with high-toned acidity and seemingly stretch the reserved flavors into an eternal finish. This needs at least seven to eight years."
94-96 points, Vinous
"Quite engaging and mercurial, the 2023 Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Grand Cru has a very impressive bouquet: hints of gingerbread and fig underscore orange rind-laced dark berry fruit and crushed stone. The palate is medium-bodied and quite persistent in the mouth, with insistent grip and a structured finish. This will require time in bottle but it should turn into an impressive Clos de la Roche."