96 points, Wine Enthusiast
"This is a rich, intense and dense wine. Aging in wood has concentrated the ripe fruit, bringing an old-gold character to the wine. It is supremely rich with flavors of molasses and also tight with great acidity. Drink this superb wine now. ROGER VOSS"
95 points, Washington Wine Blog
“An untterly sensational Madeira, the 1989 ‘Bual’ was aged for 29 years in seasoned American oak casks in the traditonal ‘Canteiro’ system before bottling in 2018. Complex brandy soaked cherry and orange rind aromas are woven together with wintergreen, quince and salted toffee tones on the nose. The palate shows great length and richness, with incredible depth and concentration. Honeydew melon and salted Macadamia nut tones meld with minerals, peat moss, brandy soaked pear and shades of sour pineapple on this evocative palate. The extraordinary, one minute long finish, provides the resounding crescendo. Gorgeous to enjoy now at the thirty one year mark, the 1989 Cossart Gordon ‘Bual’ Madeira will enjoy at least another two decades of life ahead of it. Drink 2020-2040”
93 points, Wine & Spirits
"Crunchy and remarkably fresh for a 30-year-old wine, this starts out with a cocoa richness that slowly reveals bitter-orange flavors, notes of butterscotch, golden apples and pink-grapefruit marmalade. The wine’s mellow sweetness is managed by crisply detailed acidity, so any threats of cloying intensity immediately yield to complexity as you exhale. Premium Port Wines, San Francisco, CA"